---

We live in an age obsessed with control. Modern society is an architecture of structures, schedules, five-year plans, and protocols. From our careers to our leisure, and tragically often even in our spiritual life, we try to streamline everything. We have come to believe in the myth of makeability: the idea that we ourselves are the designers of our happiness, our identity, and our meaning. We build mental and social frameworks and then expect God to manifest Himself within them. But the tragedy of modern man is that he suffocates within his own constructions. We think in structures, not in the Spirit. And precisely there we run, fundamentally, aground.

The truth we have forgotten in our hyper-organized world is at once simple and radical: the Spirit leads us, not the other way around. The moment we try to compress the divine breath into our human frames, the fire goes out. This article is a plea for the return to en-theos — true enthusiasm — and for a rediscovery of the Holy Spirit as the quiet, unstoppable power who can fill us only when we dare to release control.

The Lie of ‘Meaning-Making’

One of the most stubborn dogmas of our modern, secular culture is that you have to “make meaning.” Existentialist philosophers of the twentieth century, Jean-Paul Sartre foremost among them, taught us that life is by nature meaningless and that man, like a kind of solitary creator, must himself construct meaning. This thought has nestled itself deeply in the pores of our society. We hear it everywhere: “You must create your own truth,” or “You must give meaning to your existence yourself.”

Although they have made us believe it, it is a spiritual error. You cannot “make” meaning. Meaning and purpose are not human constructions; they are theological realities that we can only receive. Trying spasmodically to produce meaning leads inevitably to exhaustion, burn-out, and a chronic sense of emptiness. Why? Because the human soul is too large to be filled with goals we have invented for ourselves.

When we stop trying to ‘make’ meaning, we open the door to the Holy Spirit. The Spirit is not a building block for our self-designed life project. He is the designer. The theologian Hans Urs von Balthasar expressed this masterfully by emphasizing the difference between the Ego-drama and the Theo-drama. In the Ego-drama we ourselves stand at the center; we write the script, we direct the scenes, and we demand that God help us turn our play into a success. In the Theo-drama we realize that there already exists a cosmic, divine script. The meaning of our life lies not in cramped invention of a role, but in humbly listening to the Role appointed for us, and letting the Spirit lead us on the stage.

En-Theos: True Energy versus Worldly Lust

If we decide to surrender to the Spirit, we discover an entirely new form of vitality. A beautiful word for this is enthusiasm. In modern usage this word has been reduced to a superficial sort of cheerfulness, but its etymology unveils a mystical secret. It comes from the Greek en-theos, which means literally: God in us.

True, Spirit-led inspiration is a kind of energy, a deep enthusiasm. It is something one wants to give oneself to with one’s whole being, simply because it is good, true, and beautiful. But it is crucial to distinguish this divine en-theos from earthly passions or what we have traditionally called ‘lust.’

Lust — whether the lust for power, control, pleasure, or esteem — is always constraining. It is a coercive, devouring force that arises out of a deficiency, out of an ego crying for satisfaction. Lust narrows our gaze. It makes us anxious to lose what we crave. The Holy Spirit, by contrast, is not constraining. As Jesus said to Nicodemus: “The wind blows where it wills, and you hear the sound of it, but you do not know whence it comes or whither it goes; so it is with every one who is born of the Spirit” (John 3:8, RSV-CE).

The energy of the Holy Spirit is of a wholly different order than human willpower or lust. He is calm and at the same time intensely energetic. Where lust is chaotic, the Spirit brings order. Where willpower exhausts, the Spirit nourishes. He is a quiet stream of clarity that gives one the strength to move mountains, without losing oneself in nervous haste. Thomas Merton, the great twentieth-century Trappist, warned of this already. He pointed out that many of our actions — even the ‘good’ or religious ones — proceed from a neurotic need to prove ourselves. Only when we act out of the inner stillness in which God dwells do we act out of pure grace. Then the doing of the good costs no exhausting effort, but flows out of an interior necessity.

The Mystery of Letting Go

To experience this en-theos, however, we must do something that runs directly counter to the modern spirit: we must acknowledge that we have no control over it. We cannot summon the Holy Spirit like a genie from a bottle. We cannot extort grace with a perfect schedule or a pious technique. And if we have no control over the Spirit, this means inevitably that we have no absolute control over our own life.

This insight is, frankly, terrifying for modern man. We have been trained to equate the loss of control with failure. But in Christian mysticism the abandonment of control is precisely the ultimate condition of freedom. The French Jesuit Jean-Pierre de Caussade wrote on this in his spiritual masterpiece L’Abandon à la Providence Divine (Abandonment to Divine Providence). He argues that God speaks to us continually and seeks to work in us through “the sacrament of the present moment.”

We often miss God because we are too busy planning the future or mourning the past, locked inside our structures. De Caussade teaches us that surrender does not mean becoming passive, but becoming extraordinarily alert to what this particular moment asks of us, and engaging it with full devotion. We let go of the wheel, not in order to become a rudderless ship, but in order to allow the great Pilot on board.

This requires a radical spiritual disposition that the medieval theologian Meister Eckhart called Gelassenheit: serene release, or detachment. We must ‘empty’ ourselves of our own rigid plans and preconceived ideas, even our ideas about how our life of faith should look. Only when the cup of our heart is empty can the water of the Spirit be poured in.

The Litany of Humility as Liberation

This emptiness, this letting-go of control, requires one fundamental virtue: humility. The Holy Spirit Himself is humble. He does not break in with brute violence. When the prophet Elijah stood on the mountain (1 Kings 19), God was not in the devastating wind, not in the earthquake, not in the fire. He was in the gentle whisper of the wind. The voice of the Spirit is a whisper, and whispers can only be heard if you yourself are still.

The Spirit fully respects our free will. He does not coerce; He invites. We must cooperate with Him. And we can only cooperate when we are no longer full of ourselves.

Here The Litany of Humility (attributed to Cardinal Rafael Merry del Val, the Cardinal Secretary of State under Pope Pius X) offers one of the most powerful spiritual medicines of the Church. This litany prays not merely for a pious sentiment, but cuts straight through the chains of our ego:

• From the desire of being praised, deliver me, Jesus.
• From the desire of being honored, deliver me, Jesus.
• From the fear of being humiliated, deliver me, Jesus.
• From the fear of being forgotten, deliver me, Jesus.

Why is this prayer so essential in relation to the Holy Spirit? Because most of our life-structures are built on precisely these fears and longings. We build careers, reputations, and social masks because we fear being ignored or forgotten. We cling to social and cultural structures because they offer us safety and standing.

The moment we are, by grace, freed from these fears, something wondrous happens. The Spirit gets free play. The one who sincerely prays the Litany of Humility has become wholly invulnerable to the world. He is no longer a slave to the opinions of others. He stands open to a divine inspiration (en-theos) which, as it rightly may be observed, no longer takes account of the prevailing culture. The worldly culture is always founded on power, prestige, and success. The culture of the Spirit is founded on the foolishness of the cross.

The Peace of the Martyr

This leads to the ultimate expression of the Spirit-led person: the readiness for martyrdom. A martyr — from the Greek martys, meaning ‘witness’ — is not someone who, out of fanaticism, seeks death. The true Christian martyr is the one who can choose for God, against the prevailing structures, without losing his peace.

How is it possible that saints like Maximilian Kolbe or Thomas More could meet death with a perfect interior peace? Because their lives were no longer their own. They had abandoned the Ego-drama. Because they were humble, they rested in God. They did not need to defend their own meaning or life-work, because their lives had already been absorbed into the greater work of the Spirit.

This is the grace of the deep, calm energy we spoke of earlier. When you truly rest in God, and you have surrendered your own control over life to His Providence, the need to fight with the weapons of the world (aggression, fear, bitterness) disappears. You bear witness (martyrium) with an unshakable peace. The worldly powers understand nothing of this disposition; they think in power-structures, and a martyr who accepts death with a smile or a prayer immediately collapses the illusion of those earthly power-structures.

Practical: Moving with the Breath

If modern society is a labyrinth of dead structures, and the Spirit is the blowing wind of living en-theos, then how do we learn to live in that Spirit? How do we translate this lofty mysticism into our daily life?

1. Stop dictating to God: we must abandon the idea that prayer is a presentation of our own agenda items. Prayer must begin with listening. We must release the idea that we ‘make’ meaning, and ask instead to be opened to the meaning God has already laid in us.
2. Embrace uncertainty: accept that the spiritual life cannot be streamlined or pinned down. If you find yourself frustrated because your plans are not going through, do not see this as a glitch in the system, but perhaps as an intervention of the Spirit. Practice the Gelassenheit of Meister Eckhart.
3. Practice the ‘Discernment of Spirits’: this is the great lesson of Saint Ignatius of Loyola. Pay attention to the inward movements of your soul. An action or decision that springs from the ego and from modern culture may bring brief excitement, but it leaves you in the end with emptiness, restlessness, and a cramped craving for control (lust). A decision prompted by the Holy Spirit — even when that decision is very difficult, requires sacrifice, or runs against the culture — always brings a deep interior peace, consolation, and a quiet, durable energy.
4. Choose deliberately the humbling of the ego: make the Litany of Humility part of your rhythm. Each time we discover that we are acting out of a need for status or applause, we must gently correct ourselves. Humility is the runway for the Holy Spirit.

Conclusion: From Structure to River

It is time to unmask the illusion that man stands at the center of a make-able universe. Our structures, however useful they may sometimes be in practical terms, can never feed the soul. They are like canals of concrete, while the human spirit longs for living, surging water.

The Spirit does not descend on those who have everything perfectly in order, but on those who dare to admit they stand with empty hands. The Christian is called to release the cramping of control. That does not mean life becomes easier — the way of the Spirit can lead straight to the cross — but life becomes drenched with an inextinguishable enthusiasm. With en-theos. God in us.

When we cease our anxious hammering at the structures of our own ego, we discover the gentle, majestic breath of the Holy Spirit. He reigns without coercion. He leads us through the darkness, beyond the thresholds of our culture, into a perfect rest in God. The only question is: do we, at last, dare to release the wheel?